tensioning drag/antidrag wires

Post a reply

Smilies
:D :) ;) :( :o :shock: :? 8-) :lol: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :twisted: :roll: :!: :?: :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen: :geek: :ugeek:

BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON

Topic review
   

Expand view Topic review: tensioning drag/antidrag wires

Re: tensioning drag/antidrag wires

by mmarien » Tue Apr 06, 2021 3:06 pm

My neighbor said the formula was 25 lbs to deflect the anti/drag wire 1/4". I tried it. It seemed like a lot of pressure on the wire. So I did some digging. I found a couple of things. The first was this formula:

T = (L * F) / 4 * X where

T is the tension on the wire.
L is the length of the wire.
F is the force in lbs applied at right angles at the mid point of the wire.
X is the deflection of the wire

There are some caveats. The diametre of the wire needs to be much smaller than the length so the stiffness of the wire is not a factor. The force is applied at right angles at the midpoint of the wire. And the force is small compared to the tension of the wire, ie: the deflection should be much much smaller than the wire length.

So plugging in what my neighbor gave me resulted in a tension of 1000 lbs = (40 * 25) / 4 * 0.25. It didn't make a lot of sense. I found this for a Stinson:
Screenshot 2021-04-06 134748.jpg
Screenshot 2021-04-06 134748.jpg (178.16 KiB) Viewed 831 times
The tension was about a tenth of what I was told!! On some cub forums the number 1/2" deflection with 12-15 lbs of force was repeated several places. Dakota Cub was mentioned as the source. This comes out to about 240 - 300 lbs tension. My neighbor is building a J3. His wires are smaller than 3/16" I hope he doesn't have 1000 lbs tension on them.

So between the Stinson diagram and what Juerg Mueller said above makes a lot of sense.

PS: for those with a good ear, someone on the Internet said that the twang the wire makes should be "G" on a musical scale. I'm going to use my fish scale and 5 lbs force with 1/2" deflection which would put about 100 lbs tension of the wires. I also may check the twang. You never know. Build a Hatz is probably part artistry.

Re: tensioning drag/antidrag wires

by JBMoore » Wed Feb 20, 2019 7:04 am

I had a two sets of aluminum jaws made that were held together by a 10-32 screw.
They were big enough for me to use an adjustable wrench and I put one set on each end of the wire so I didn't introduce any twist.

Jeff Moore

Re: tensioning drag/antidrag wires

by Mark K » Tue Feb 19, 2019 5:15 pm

Thanks for the reply Al, That sounds easy enough. I'll give it a try.
Thanks Again
Mark

Re: tensioning drag/antidrag wires

by alvinsager » Mon Feb 18, 2019 9:18 am

Hi,
I made a pair of hardwood jaws for a small vise-grip that had a groove for the wire. Worked fine.
Al

Re: tensioning drag/antidrag wires

by Mark K » Mon Feb 18, 2019 8:35 am

I'm assembling my first wing and wanted to trammel the wing before I glued up the ribs. I'm building the classic with tabs on the compression struts. I made my antidrag wires from round stainless clamped in a bench vise with aluminum stock to protect the wires as I cut the threads, worked great.

My question is how do I grip the anti drag wire in the tensioning process now that its in the wing?
- Can I file flats for a small wrench to fit without weakening the wire?

In an earlier post Hans and Sam have beautiful wires that are square, can I do that in a small section without compromising the wires? How do the guys with round wires grip the wire without maring it? Once covered I'd have to be able to adjust the tension through an inspection cover right?
Thanks
Mark

Re: tensioning drag/antidrag wires

by Bitshifter » Tue Apr 14, 2015 8:09 am

I noticed that you assembled and rigged the Hatz before covering the wings. I am wondering if you happened to check the drag / antidrag wires at that point. I wonder if the flying wire rigging may have "tweeked" the wings a bit. I am interested in this answer since I will be doing it at some point in the future. I was also wondering if the tabs on the compression struts were just a little off angle then the tension would be reduced as flying stress created the proper angle.
Please continue to post your findings and experiences as I find them to be very helpful.

Thanks
Ed

Re: tensioning drag/antidrag wires

by kconner » Mon Apr 13, 2015 10:00 pm

Hello Hans & Sam
After I completed the wing panels for my CB-1 I applied two coats of epoxy-varnish with a brush. The wings were stored hanging on a rack for approximately 5 years. When I began the covering process I first had to re-tension ALL of the drag and anti-drag rods. All of the rods had lost tension. I believe the wings did shrink even though they were thoroughly coated with varnish. This is why I would recommend completing the wings first when building a Hatz. Re-tighten the rods and I think they will hold tension until your next inspection.

Kevin

Re: tensioning drag/antidrag wires

by stearmoth » Mon Apr 13, 2015 5:39 am

Hi Jürg and Hatz buddies,

Upon Sam's first annual inspection he found that the drag (not antidrag) wires in the first bay (left and right to the tank) in the top wings are much less tight than they were when installed and tensionned before covering. According to your suggestion, we didn't tensioning them to much, we did it just by "feeling" and never checked this afterwards, also did not before first flight.
As we testloaded all wires up to the max. allowable stress, it seems not be possible, that this relief occured due to overstress in flight!
Might it be possible, that this comes from the flying wires tension?
What is your recommandation, should we retensionning those drag wires until they feel tight?
Anyway, last Saturday Sam made the first flight this year with 3 smart landings - all went well!

Kindest regards
Hans & Sam, H.C.#78, Switzerland

Re: tensioning drag/antidrag wires

by Nick » Sat Apr 23, 2011 4:34 pm

Juerg, that is a very helpful post. Thanks for taking the time.

Nick

Re: tensioning drag/antidrag wires

by stearmoth » Wed Jan 19, 2011 12:34 pm

Hi Jackal,

Thank you for your comment! Yes, we would make such wires available. Please drop us an email to hans.u@aeroplaneworks.ch and I will send you a quote.
We are delighted with our drag/antidrag wires as they meet with ease the AN703 specs. (same strenght as Bruntons round drawn tie rods). We make them with a 1/8" square section and rolled UNF 10-32 threads (left- and righthand) from AISI 316 stainless steel. We test loaded each wire for security. Those set of wires weights 2.6 lbs. less than with ordinary round dia 3/16" tie rods.

Kind regards

Hans & Sam, H.C.#78, Switzerland

Top